By John J. Mearsheimer and Stephen M. Walt Mearsheimer and Walt use realist national-interest analysis to deftly deconstruct the usual justifications for. The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy is a book by John Mearsheimer, Professor of Political Science at the University of Chicago, and Stephen Walt,  Published‎: ‎August 27, Farrar, Straus and. Stephen M. Walt. Mearsheimer responds to Goldberg's latest smear. Ever since John Mearsheimer and I began writing about the Israel lobby.


Author: Ms. Gage Greenholt
Country: Eswatini
Language: English
Genre: Education
Published: 3 December 2014
Pages: 245
PDF File Size: 36.26 Mb
ePub File Size: 36.25 Mb
ISBN: 610-5-90660-443-2
Downloads: 19012
Price: Free
Uploader: Ms. Gage Greenholt


Despite its many flaws, their essay has performed a very useful service in forcing into the open a subject that has for too long remained taboo. But he asserts that he did not find the thesis of the paper very convincing. He said that Stephen Zunes has rightly pointed out that "there are far more powerful interests that have a stake in what happens in the Persian Gulf region than does AIPAC [or the Lobby generally], such as john mearsheimer stephen walt oil companies, the arms industry and other special interests whose lobbying influence and campaign contributions far surpass that of the much-vaunted Zionist lobby and its allied donors to congressional races.

It's a narrative that recounts every lurid report of Israeli cruelty as indisputable fact but leaves out the rise of Fatah and Palestinian terrorism before ; the Munich Olympics; Black September; myriad cases of suicide bombings; and other spectaculars.

Mearsheimer and Walt provide one: In this respect, their account is not so much a diagnosis of our polarized era as a symptom of it.

How Not to Think About the Israel Lobby – Foreign Policy

John mearsheimer stephen walt observes that their definition of the "Israel lobby" is amorphous to the point of being useless: Mead considers their wider geopolitical analysis "more professional" but still "simplistic and sunny" on alternatives to a U. Mead rejects any antisemitic intent in the work, but feels that the authors left themselves open to the charge through "easily avoidable lapses in judgment and expression.

Yet their work is john mearsheimer stephen walt travesty of the history that I have studied and written for the past two decades. Their work is riddled with shoddiness and defiled by mendacity.

Mearsheimer responds to Goldberg’s latest smear

Where Mearsheimer and Walt are on their strongest ground is in saying, as foreign-policy realists, that the Israeli alliance is very costly for the United States, and that's where American supporters of Israel are on their weakest ground.

Those john mearsheimer stephen walt sometimes claim that the alliance is based on the affinity so many Americans supposedly feel for Israel, but at the same time they "bend over backward to help people understand that help for Israel is also in America's strategic interests", as Hyman Bookbinder of the American Jewish Committee put it.


But by now it must be obvious to an intelligent year-old, in Baghdad, Jenin, Tel Aviv or even Washington, that the Israeli alliance, far from advancing American interests, gravely damages them and has hindered every American endeavour in Arab countries or the whole Muslim world.

The alliance could still be defended in terms of loyalty john mearsheimer stephen walt sentiment - America and Israel "contra mundum" - but the lobbyists and the neocons have painted themselves into a corner with that exorbitant language of "strategic interests".

Even so, whatever may be said about Israel or its advocates, the people who come out far and away the worst from this story are American politicians; and The Israel Lobby had the most unusual effect of making me rather proud of my country and its parliament. After describing john mearsheimer stephen walt was happening with Obama, Atzmon notes that this kind of behavior is hardly unprecedented.

In his words, "Jewish lobbies certainly do not hold back when it comes to pressuring states, world leaders and even superpowers. His basic point is that the Jewish boycott had negative consequences, which it did.

On the contrary, he believes Jews have considerable agency and their actions are not always wise. In fact, he says nothing about the Holocaust in his post and he certainly does not justify in any way the murder of six million Jews.

Goldberg ends his attack on me with the following quotation from a Feb. But Goldberg has misrepresented what Atzmon really said, which is one of his standard tactics.

The entire sentence reads: Finally, let me address the charge that Atzmon himself is an anti-Semite and a self-hating Jew. I do not believe that Atzmon is an anti-Semite, although that charge is thrown john mearsheimer stephen walt so carelessly these days that it has regrettably lost much of its meaning.

Mearsheimer responds to Goldberg’s latest smear – Foreign Policy

If one believes that anyone who criticizes Israel is an anti-Semite, then Atzmon clearly fits in that category. But that definition is foolish — no country is perfect or above criticism-and john mearsheimer stephen walt worth taking seriously. The more important and interesting issue is whether Atzmon is a self-hating Jew.

Here the answer is unequivocally yes. He openly describes himself in this way and he sees himself as part of a long dissident tradition that includes famous figures such as Marx and John mearsheimer stephen walt.

The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy - Wikipedia

What is going on here? The key to understanding Atzmon is that he rejects the claim that Jews are the "Chosen People.


Accordingly, pro-Israel organisations work hard to influence the institutions that do most to shape popular opinion. Conversely, he found just five pundits who consistently criticise Israeli actions or endorse Arab positions.

Related Post